Don't Believe the Hype: Let's Dissect the Best Ice Fishing Reels

Find the perfect ice fishing reel for your next winter fishing adventure! Our top picks for the best ice fishing reels are expert-reviewed for top performance, reliability and affordability. Choose your winner now!

Tired of trial and error when it comes to finding the perfect ice fishing reel?

If you are sick of wasting money on reels that turn out to be duds, then don't worry, we have got you covered. We have explored our unbiased perspectives on the best ice fishing reels in terms of quality, features, and value for money.

Now there's no need to rely on luck when shopping - just trust in us as we provide honest critiques and ratings so you don't spend too much money unnecessarily or buy something that doesn't fit your style at all.

Check out our blog post now for detailed analysis and comprehensive reviews about different types of reels available today so that next time you go out onto the frozen lake ready with confidence!

Selecting the Best Ice Fishing Reels

Selecting the best ice fishing reel can be a challenging task for anglers, with so many options available in the market.

There are several factors that must be considered when choosing the right ice fishing reel, such as weight capacity, gear ratio, line capacity, retrieve speed, handle design, and more. With so many options available, it can be overwhelming and confusing to determine which one will meet your specific needs and provide a successful fishing experience.

To help anglers select the best ice fishing reel, our team of experts we have researched several popular options on the market. We have also considered feedback from experienced ice anglers and finally compiled a list of the top 6 choices for their reliability, durability, and ease of use. So, take a look and find the best ice fishing reel that suits your needs and budget!

We know you want the best, so we work hard to provide it. Our team of experts is constantly selecting products for our site that meet high standards and offer great value too! Our opinions are based on independent trials and tests but as an Amazon Associate, we may earn from some qualifying purchases. This helps us to keep the site running without costing anything extra for you.

Piscifun ICX Frost Ice Fishing Reel

Best Overall

Check Price On Amazon

The Piscifun ICX Frost Ice Fishing Reel is the best way to reel in that icy catch! Featuring a FreeSpool trigger, you can drop lures beneath the ice quickly and easily. Plus, its clever design allows for single-handed use so you don’t have to put down your rod.

Best of all, it comes with magnetic speed control buttons for micro adjustments on the rate of falling of lures. Crafted from carbon fiber material, this reel stays lightweight yet still strong enough to land those big catches.

Crafted from CNC aluminum alloy, this reel offers superior corrosion resistance and strength to ensure it stands up to even the toughest of conditions. Moreover, its double-shielded stainless steel ball bearings effectively guard against rust and provide a smooth cast as well as retrieval performance.

Get yourself an ICX Frost inline ice fishing reel and make sure your next bite doesn't slip away!

Why You Will Love This

·       Looks great and has a superior smooth performance.

·       Great customer service.

·      This reel utilizes a unique, frozen grease formula that ensures the reels run smoothly and without any blockages.

What Could Have Been Better

·       Not a very budget-friendly option.

·       The plastic parts on the handle can break after extensive use.

KastKing Zephyr Spinning Reel

Best Ultralight Reel

Check Price On Amazon

Kastking reels have become very popular very fast among anglers and this Zephyr spinning reel is their ultra-lightweight champion among spinning ice fishing reels! This reel is exceptionally smooth and boasts quality craftsmanship that's suitable for both fresh water and saltwater. It comes in 5 size options, and 2 color options and the ultralight 500 size is best if you want to ice fish for crappies.

Best yet, it works for all types of fishing lines so reel in your catch with confidence no matter the conditions. The KastKing Zephyr spinning ice fishing reel truly has it all; power, speed, precision - you name it! And thanks to its stainless steel ball bearings, you will get a smooth operation every time.

It features an ultra-smooth carbon fiber drag and corrosion-free graphite body to keep it lightweight yet durable, making it ideal for even the harshest weather conditions. The reel also has a braid-ready CNC machined aluminum spool that prevents braided lines from slipping under pressure, providing anglers with smooth and reliable performance every time they hit the ice.

Fishing can be an adventure even in the coldest weather if you've got this best-in-class spinning wheel by your side. So don't delay - get yours today and experience effortless catches with every cast!

Why You Will Love This

·       The attractive design and the eye-catching neon green color (there's also a black color option).

·       Great for catching panfish.

·       Lightweight and the size 500 reel weighs only 5.6 oz.

·       The EVA foam handle pedal is comfortable to hold for long hours.

What Could Have Been Better

·       Lacks a reverse switch.

13 Fishing Black Betty Freefall Ghost

Best Inline Ice Fishing Reels

Check Price On Amazon

The 13 Fishing Black Betty Freefall Ghost will be your new best friend on ice-fishing expeditions! This easy-to-use reel keeps your line straight and tight, even in deep water settings.

The 13 Fishing Black Betty Freefall Ghost is the best inline ice fishing reel on the market, boasting revolutionary features that make it perfect for any angler looking to maximize their time on the ice. With just a few clicks you can adjust the depths with a super smooth release, even when you are using lighter jigs - no more hand cramps or troublesome triggers!

With a user-friendly design, this reel ensures zero line twist and tangle-free spooling so you can enjoy a hassle-free experience. Get ready to reel in that big catch with ease and convenience!

Why You Will Love This

·       You can drop your ice fishing lure quickly, without worrying about missing bites.

·       Comes with an instant stop anti-reverse feature.

·       You will love the smooth retrieval option.

What Could Have Been Better

·       Has a tendency to freeze.

Abu Garcia Ice Max Spinning Reels

Best Budget Pick

Check Price On Amazon

Abu Garcia Ice Max Spinning Reels, are a great value pick for any ice angler. With its super-smooth action and collapsible handle, the packing will be a breeze! Plus, you'll love the well-designed and well-built construction of this reel.

The Abu Garcia Ice Max Spinning Reel is a reliable reel designed to meet the needs of any angler. With its lightweight graphite body and rotor, and machined aluminum spool you will get uncompromised durability for years.

And thanks to its 4-bearing system this spinning reel provides superior smooth performance in all conditions. Whether you’re an experienced fisherman or just starting out, the Abu Garcia Ice Max Spinning Reel is sure to exceed your expectations.

Why You Will Love This

·       Clever handle design that provides great grip.

·       Easy to store and transport, thanks to the one-touch collapsible handle design.

·       Will withstand years of abuse and a large aluminum strip will ensure that your line remains tangle free.

·      Budget-friendly pick.

What Could Have Been Better

·      Not powerful enough for large fish.

·      There's no reverse switch present.

Pflueger Moniceb Monarch Ice Spinning Reel

Best for Walleyes

Check Price On Amazon

Make your ice fishing trips more fun with the Pflueger Moniceb Monarch Ice Spinning Reel! It has a smooth action that can help you reel in those big walleyes. It has a lightweight graphite construction and is a very well-built product that doesn't cost a fortune.

This durable reel features corrosion-resistant stainless steel ball bearings, making it perfect for use in cold weather conditions. The bail wire is made up of rigid aluminum, designed to be tough and provide a smooth action every time.

Get ready for some serious fish catching this season with the Pflueger Moniceb Monarch Ice Spinning Reel!

Why You Will Love This

·       The 5-bearing system provides an incredibly smooth performance.

·       The long handle design might feel awkward at first, but it is actually easier and more comfortable to use.

·       It has a smooth drag system, which ensures consistent and reliable performance.

What Could Have Been Better

·       It has no anti-reverse switch

·       Can be difficult to carry as it feels heavy and has a long handle that does not collapse unless unscrewed.

Goture Mini Pocket Metal Spinning Fishing Reel

Best Portable Reel

Check Price On Amazon

Are you looking to get into the exciting world of ice fishing but don't want to spend a fortune? Look no further than the Goture Mini Pocket Metal Spinning Fishing Reel!

This mini pocket-sized reel is ideal for beginners and can make an amazing gift. It has a surprisingly durable aluminum alloy built with a copper main shaft. Constructed with a CNC full aluminum spool, this reel provides great balance and stability during casting and winding, even in cold temperatures.

The Alloy Drive Gear provides excellent drag power and you will notice a smooth retrieval. But best of all, it includes a collapsible handle with a wooden knob that can be easily unscrewed and screwed back together when you need to change your hand orientation.

Now, pick up one lightweight spinning rod and this nice reel for great value on an unbeatable budget! Get ready for some chilly fun with the Best Ice Fishing Reels around.

Why You Will Love This

·      Extremely budget-friendly.

·      Portable and lightweight.

·      Provides smooth reeling thanks to its gapless bearings.

·      You will love the design and build quality, especially the cork handle.

What Could Have Been Better

·      At this price, it is hard to complain about anything, but you have to keep your expectations realistic.

Frequently Asked Questions

Understanding the different aspects of ice fishing reels can be confusing and overwhelming, especially for new ice anglers.

With so many factors to consider, choosing the right ice fishing reel can be a daunting task. This can lead to frustration and disappointment when it comes to fishing on the ice.

To help ease your concerns, we have compiled a list of frequently asked questions about ice fishing reels. These will cover the most important aspects of selecting the right reel, so you can make an informed decision and complete your ice fishing gear list with ease. So sit back, relax, and let us answer your questions about ice fishing reels.

How do I choose an ice fishing reel?

Choosing the right ice fishing reel can be a bit of a challenge, but don't worry, we're here to help! Here are some key factors you should consider when selecting your reel:

· Drag System: Look for a reel with a smooth and consistent drag system. This will help you easily and effectively control the line during a catch.

· Line Capacity: A good ice fishing reel should have enough line capacity to handle the size of fish you're targeting.

· Ball Bearings: The number of ball bearings in the reel can affect its smoothness and durability. Generally, the more ball bearings, the better.

· Gear Ratio: The gear ratio refers to the number of rotations the spool makes for every turn of the handle. Higher gear ratios mean faster retrieval, which can be helpful when reeling in a big catch.

· Line Retrieval: Consider the speed of line retrieval when you are reeling in a fish. A high-speed line retrieval will help you to reel in a fish more quickly.

· Line Type: Some reels are designed to work best with a specific type of line, such as braided or fluorocarbon. Be sure to choose a reel that is compatible with the type of line you plan to use.

· Budget: Finally, set a budget for yourself and look for a reel that fits within your price range while still meeting your other criteria.

What gear ratio for ice fishing?

The gear ratio of a fishing reel refers to the number of times the rotor rotates around the spool for each full rotation of the handle. A higher gear ratio means that the spool will rotate faster, allowing you to retrieve the line more quickly, this is especially helpful for casting at longer distances.

While a lower gear ratio provides more power for fighting larger fish at short distances but lower depths. When it comes to ice fishing, a gear ratio closer to 4.5:1 to 5.2:1 is a good range to consider. This range offers a good balance between retrieval speed and power.

However, if you plan to target smaller fish, a gear ratio of 6.2:1 or higher might be a better choice, as it will allow you to retrieve the ice fishing line more quickly. On the other hand, if you plan to target larger fish, a gear ratio of 3.8:1 or lower might be more suitable, as it provides more power for fighting larger fish.

What size reel for ice fishing lake trout?

When it comes to ice fishing for lake trout, you should choose a larger reel. This is because lake trout tend to be larger than other fish species that are commonly targeted in ice fishing. Reels that are designed for heavier lines and bigger lures will give you the best chance of catching these large fish.

Generally speaking, it is recommended to use a larger reel when fishing for lake trout – usually, one that is 2500 or 3500 size. This size of the reel will give you the right amount of power and leverage when battling these larger fish. Additionally, it's important to make sure your line matches the size of your reel.

What size reel should I use for ice fishing?

When it comes to ice fishing, the size of the reel you should use depends on the species of fish you're targeting and the type of bait being used. The most common reel used is an ultralight size spinning reel, which is great for smaller fishes such as panfish and perch.

A typical ice fishing spinning reel will be a 1000-size model, which is capable of handling 4lb or 6lb test lines. This size is great for all-around use.

If you're targeting larger fish such as pike or walleye, then you may want to opt for a larger reel of a size around 2000. These reels are stronger and can handle the weight of larger fish, especially when using heavier lines.

The type of line you use also plays a role in choosing the right reel size. If you're using a lightweight monofilament line, a smaller reel will suffice, but if you're using a braided or fluorocarbon line, you may want to opt for a larger reel to handle the increased strength.

It's also important to consider the size of your rod, which will dictate the size of the reel you can use. Most rods will specify the size range of the reel that's compatible with it, so be sure to check the manufacturer's specifications before making a purchase.

Can you put a regular reel on an ice fishing rod?

Yes, you can put a regular reel on an ice fishing rod. However, it is important to keep in mind that ice fishing rods are typically shorter and more sensitive than regular fishing rods, so a specialized reel designed for ice fishing may be better suited for the job.

Generally, regular reels do not have the same function or design as those specifically made for ice fishing. Ice fishing reels typically have a smaller line capacity and slower retrieve speed to accommodate the slow, methodical jigging style used in ice fishing.

It allows you to pull in large fish without extreme strain on your gear. Ice fishing reels also come with features such as line counters and level winds, which make it easier to fish in cold conditions.

Using a regular reel on an ice fishing rod could result in a loss of control over the line or a lack of performance when trying to land your catch. For these reasons, it's generally recommended to use an ice fishing reel when out on the ice.

Why use an inline ice fishing reel?

Inline ice fishing reels are a great choice for ice anglers, especially in areas where the bite is hard and you need to go deeper.

Inline reels are designed specifically for use in cold temperatures and feature a streamlined, lightweight design that sits directly in line with the rod. Also, they can dive deeper smoothly without any noticeable wobbly movement which can happen with the common ultralight fishing reels.

This makes them easier to maneuver and helps reduce line twists when fighting your catch. Additionally, an inline reel will provide you increased sensitivity so you can feel even the slightest bite, allowing you to set the hook fast and easily land your fish.

Are there any maintenance tips for my ice fishing reel?

Yes, there are some maintenance tips you can follow to keep your ice fishing reel in good condition. Here are a few:

· Clean and oil the reel after each use to prevent salt and ice buildup.

· Store the reel in a dry place to prevent rust and corrosion.

· Check the line periodically to ensure it's not frayed or tangled.

· If the reel becomes frozen, do not try to force it open. Instead, warm it up slowly and gently to avoid damaging the mechanism.

· If you notice any strange noises or wobbling while using the reel, stop using it and have it inspected by a professional.

By following these tips, you can help ensure your ice fishing reel remains in good condition and performs well for years to come.

Should I Choose a Left or Right-Handed Ice Fishing Reel?

When selecting an ice fishing reel, make sure to match it with your dominant hand. If you are right-handed, opt for a right-hand reel and if a lefty is more of your orientation, then go ahead and choose a left-hand one.

How do you attach a reel to an ice rod?

Attaching a reel to an ice rod is a simple process that can typically be done in a few steps:

· Gather your equipment: You'll need your ice rod, reel, and line.

· Attach the reel seat: Most ice rods have a reel seat, which is the component that holds the reel in place on the rod. To attach the reel, simply screw the seat onto the rod.

· Mount the reel: Once the reel seat is attached, you can mount the reel to the rod. Line up the spool of the reel with the reel seat and screw the reel in place, making sure it is securely attached.

· Load the line: Once the reel is attached, you can load the line onto the spool. Make sure the line is loaded correctly, following the manufacturer's instructions, and make sure there are no tangles in the line.

What is the price range for a good quality ice fishing reel?

The price range for a good quality ice fishing reel can vary greatly depending on the brand, model, and features. On the lower end, you can find basic ice fishing reels for around $20 to $30. Mid-range reels can cost anywhere from $50 to $100, and high-end reels can cost upwards of $200 or more.

When it comes to choosing an ice fishing reel, it's important to consider not only the price, but also the quality, reliability, and durability of the reel. You want to choose a reel that will provide you with a good fishing experience, and also last for several seasons.

Final Words on the Best Ice Fishing Reels

Choosing the best ice fishing reel is an important decision that can greatly impact your fishing experience. By considering all the factors we mentioned, you can ensure that you choose a reel that will meet your specific needs and provide you with a successful and enjoyable fishing experience.

The reels we've highlighted in this article have been carefully selected by our team of experts and tested to provide reliable, durable, and easy-to-use performance. Whether you are a seasoned ice angler or just starting out, these reels are sure to help you catch more fish and make the most of your time on the ice.

So why wait? Just click the "Check Price on Amazon" buttons now and add these top-performing ice fishing reels to your shopping cart. With their exceptional performance and unbeatable value, they are the perfect choice for any ice angler looking to take their fishing game to the next level!

Best Ice Fishing Reels
Gear up for ice fishing, with the best ice fishing reels